When Was The Rob Ugliest? [POLL]

I need an opinion.  This is an argument I've been a part of dating back to September when I posted my back to school pictures from grade school. You can check out that post HERE if you want to, but I warn you, pictures of me as an adolescent are EXTREMELY hard to look at and only intended for a mature audience.

I'll make this short, sweet, and to the point.  In my previous article, I referred to my TENTH GRADE photo (green shirt, 4 chins) as the worst photograph ever taken in all of history.  I'll include it here as a reminder.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

While this baffles me, my fiance actually thinks I have taken a worse photo.  She thinks that my NINTH GRADE photo (black shirt, 3 chins) is actually the worst photo of me ever taken.  I'll include that one here as well.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Please help me settle this debate.  Which phase of my life was actually more hideous, 9th grade or 10th grade?

The Hirschbuhl Collection