Indiana Sports Betting in 2026 – What You Need to Know
This content was produced in partnership with covers.com.
Indiana's sports bettors got back into football season in a big way this year, as betting handle surged to $540 million. That was up 47% compared to August's numbers, and up 1.7% against September 2025. Although overall spend was up, revenue failed to match the growth as sportsbooks hold fell during a relatively tough month for operators.
Despite bettors' enthusiasm for the new football season, some things about the experience will have been different from last year. For one, prediction markets have changed up the competition - with many new apps offering the ability to put down money on sports while being regulated as financial trading. Secondly, Indiana's gambling regulators have tinkered with the edges of sports betting rules including rejecting the National Collegiate Athletic Associations proposal to ban prop bets on college sports.
You might not personally be a bettor - but the business is worth tens of millions of tax dollars yearly in Indiana alone and employs many thousands of people, so it's a sector of economic importance. This article will look in more detail at some of those changes, and what they mean for sports bettors in Evansville and wider tri-state region.
Betting Spend Soars in September, Sportsbooks Hold Down
Bettors in Indiana put down $540 million across September, significantly more than the $367 million wagered in August. This was likely driven by the return of college football and the NFL. Several big teams in Indiana and Kentucky returned to action over the month including the Indianapolis Colts and the Tennessee Titans.
Interestingly, despite total wagering (handle) being up 47%, sportsbooks won back around 1% less of bets than they did in August. Revenues consequently rose around 33% to $49 million, compared with August's $36 million. Compared year-on-year, total handle was up around 1.7% while revenues were up 20%.
Whilst no direct correlation can be made between the divergence of betting handle and revenue growth for Indiana sportsbooks in September, several key results in the NFL and college football were upset results. The Colts pulled off an early upset victory in Texas and the Louisville Cardinals football team lost to the hefty underdog Wake Forest - which could have hurt sportsbooks with substantial exposure on the Kentucky team.
Overall football was the biggest sport for bettors in the state in September, by some way. It accounted for $154 million of the $540 million total handle. Over 2026 so far, baseball is still the most popular with $204 million wagered - but the gap is narrowing and football should overtake it by the end of the year.
New Market Dynamics Not Playing Out in Indiana
Interestingly, Indiana's bettors seem not to have been swayed in significant numbers by prediction markets - or at least not enough to impact handle during the opening of football season. There has been much discussion nationally of these newly popular platforms taking custom from sportsbooks, which many thought might become obvious during the opening NFL weeks.
In Indiana, where regulators have taken a light touch on prediction markets so far (unlike some) this hasn't seemed to have played out so far.
For now, the same top US betting sites as rated by Covers are still doing roaring business in Indiana. Expert comparative resources like Covers make a good snapshot of the market and the various operators, as well as the exact bonuses and features they have available.
College Football Prop Betting Ban Rejected
Speaking of changes in college football, things could have been very different for Indiana bettors this season - but the Indiana Gaming Commission decided otherwise.
The NCAA had requested that the regulator impose a full ban on state-licensed sportsbooks offering proposition bets on college football games. For the uninitiated that means things like player's individual yardage or points scored.
The NCAA says that such bets contribute to athlete abuse, either at games or on social media. It petitioned the IGC in late 2025, and then the regulator deferred making a decision on the issue in June. However, in September 2026, just in time for the start of the college football season, the IGC decided to reject the request.
While members were concerned about athlete abuse, they said causal link between the proposition bets in sports and the issue was unclear. They also added that elected lawmakers should ultimately be the ones to decide how to deal with it. In the meantime, live prop bets on college sports (such wagers placed on individual players during the game) remain unavailable at Indiana sportsbooks.
What Bettors Should Be Watching out For in the Future
The next monthly report from the Indiana Gaming Commission will be an important one. It is due on November 13. October's data will tell whether Indiana's bettors sustained a surge in interest in the new NFL and college football seasons, beyond opening month hype.
Likely regulation will continue to evolve, and it is doubtful the NCAA will give up its campaign on college sports prop bets. In Kentucky, Governor Andy Beshear recently vetoed a House Bill that would have introduced such a ban in The Bluegrass State. So it is possible that issue could be back in discussion later in the season or next year.
Prediction markets are also an issue that will continue to evolve, as they boom in popularity nationally. While Indiana's regulators have stayed away so far, should a potential Supreme Court ruling change the situation then they will likely react.
If you or anyone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.
