9 ‘American Idol’ Contestants Who Definitely Should Have Won9 ‘American Idol’ Contestants Who Definitely Should Have WonFrom Melinda Doolittle to Pia Toscano, these eliminated finalists deserved MUCH better.Matthew Scott DonnellyMatthew Scott Donnelly
Phil Phillips Becomes Newest American Idol [POLL]Phil Phillips Becomes Newest American Idol [POLL]Your 11th American Idol... Mr. Phillip Phillips.The RobThe Rob
Jessica Sanchez Stuns Idol Audience [VIDEO]Jessica Sanchez Stuns Idol Audience [VIDEO]Possibly the best performance in the history of the show.The RobThe Rob