Recently, we did a poll asking our listeners what local pizzeria has the best pizza in the tri-state. The response was overwhelming! Here's what YOU picked as your favorites:

 

 

  • 1

    Papa Murphy's

    CLICK HERE FOR THE MENU

    Locations (click below):

    Evansville

    Owensboro

    Papa Murphy's pizzas start with dough made in our store daily and are topped with 100% real mozzarella, hand-sliced veggies and butcher-quality meats. Take home a fresh pizza tonight and experience the Best Pizza Chain in America as rated by Zagat 2012, 2011, and 2010 National Restaurant Chains Survey.

    papa murphys
  • 2

    Turoni's Pizza and Brewery

    CLICK HERE FOR THE MENU

    Locations: 

    8011 Bell Oaks Dr., Newburgh • 812.490.5555

    408 North Main St., Evansville  812.424.9871

    4 North Weinbach Ave., Evansville • 812.477.7500

    Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery takes great pride in serving you, and we thank you. We are dedicated to warm and friendly service to our guests by employees who give a damn. We pledge to provide the best products at the best value. If we are not proud of it we WILL NOT serve it!

    turonis
  • 3

    54 Pizza Express

    CLICK HERE FOR THE MENU

    Locations:

    3101 Alvey Park Dr. Owensboro

    1700 Starlite Dr. Owensboro

    Every pizza, and all other food items at 54 Pizza Express are made with wholesome quality ingredients... fresh vegetables... delectable meats... rich tangy tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella cheese! All carefully selected for their quality and taste. You'll love our special blend of spices and cheeses! Whether for delivery, carry-out or eating in either of our two convenient locations we know you'll enjoy our extensive menu.

     

    54 Pizza Express
  • 4

    Lucy Bella's

    CLICK HERE FOR THE MENU

    Location:

    2201 Hwy 41 N., Henderson, KY  270-212-2352

    Locally owned and operated in Henderson, Kentucky. We are committed to providing you with delicious pizza, pasta and sandwiches prepared with the freshest ingredients. We purchase many of our ingredients locally to ensure freshness and in support of our community.

    Lucy Bellas
  • 5

    Big M's Pizzeria

    CLICK HERE FOR THE MENU

    Locations:

    1313 N. 1st Ave Evansville - 812-434-6909

    Family owned and operated, Big M’s Pizzeria has been making the freshest pizza in Evansville, Indiana, for more than 10 years. All of our ingredients are fresh and our pizzas are made-to-order. At Big M’s Pizzeria, nothing is ever frozen. We make our dough, our sauces and our dressings from scratch here in our kitchen because we know you can taste a difference.

    Big M's Pizzeria