The Rob & I have a disagreement about American Idol performaces, and I'd like t get your thoughts.

During last nights performances, I was less than impressed with almost every performance... And THEN it happened. Joshua Ledet took the stage, and it was OUTSTANDING!! Watch him perform When A Man Loves A Woman, by Percy Sledge.

Last week, Jessica Sanchez gave a beautiful performance of I Will Always Love You, from Whitney Houston.  Rob thinks it is far superior to Joshua's performance. Take a look at Jessica's performance.

Personally, I found Jessica's I Will Always Love You performance, while outstanding, to pale in comparison to Joshua's When A Man Loves A Woman. Rob thinks I'm crazy, and that Jessica was by far better. I'd love to know who you thought gave the better performance. Cast your vote now.